By Cathy Cassata April 30, 2020
As stay-in-place orders continue to stay in place, many people turn to social media outlets to connect with others and express their feelings about the pandemic.
But can our posts represent how we’re psychologically and emotionally handling the situation without us realizing it?
Amit Sheth, PhD, a professor and founding director of the Artificial Intelligence Institute at the University of South Carolina, says yes.
Since mid-March, Sheth has used artificial intelligence techniques to collect and analyze over 700 million tweets on Twitter and about 700,000 news articles about the COVID-19 pandemic.
His intention is to better understand how Americans are dealing with depression, anxiety, and addiction caused by COVID-19.
“The primary analysis shows the expected impact of triggers–increased cases and deaths, and school and business closings–that we capture as a Social Quality Index, which aggregates indicators of mental health and addiction,” he told Healthline.
By dissecting the data in different ways, such as by geography, time, and demographics, Sheth said patterns emerge.
For example, different generations show different responses to the COVID-19 pandemic.
He used algorithms to estimate age and categorize into three age ranges:
- GenZ: Under 23 years old
- Millenials: 23 to 35 years old
- Other: Anyone older than 35
While teenagers and young working adults are experiencing the same objective threats, Sheth said they interpret and respond to them differently.
“Young working adults revealed a consistent initial negative reaction that tended to stabilize over time. Aggregated measures of mental health can mask underlying concerning patterns, particularly in teenagers. They may not explicitly demonstrate increased anxiety and depression content initially, but instead, compensate with substance abuse. Though maladaptive, this pattern may suggest a lack of self-awareness,” he said.
Carol Landau, PhD, professor of psychiatry at Brown University and author of Mood Prep 101: A Parent’s Guide to Preventing Depression and Anxiety in College-Bound Teens, said rates of depression and anxiety have been rising in teens since before the pandemic.
While young adults have maintained some life structure while working from home, Landau says teens have been isolated from their friends, which is a major motivator for going to school.
“Teens often turn to substances; it may not be a lack of ‘self-awareness’ so much as a lack of access to care,” Landau told Healthline.
Tweets point to self-medicating
Sheth’s analysis showed increases in addiction and substance use-related content, which indicates that the public may be self-medicating.
“This suggests a future increased need for treatment, against a worrisome lack of treatment resources prior to the outbreak. The increase in substance abuse content that we see in social media also anticipates an increase in domestic violence, which is, in fact, being reported in some police precincts and domestic violence hotlines,” he said.
“This is exactly the kind of warning that we aim to provide responders so that they can predict rather than merely react to surge,” Sheth added.
Landau agreed that the pandemic has revealed barriers to mental healthcare. She said it’s also shown that unemployment and poverty are barriers to getting help.
“Isolation is one factor that makes intimate partner violence [IPV] worse, so this type of severe isolation may make it much, much worse for victims to get help. And more children are being exposed to IPV as they are home with their families,” she said.
Posts vary from state to state
While mental health has worsened nationwide due to the impact of COVID-19, Sheth said the response isn’t uniform.
His analysis shows more negative indicators and trends for states that are more harshly impacted by COVID-19.
However, he said it’s more informative to observe a change over time within a state rather than absolute values.
“For example, in Michigan, mental health among the younger population went from moderate to alarming in the weeks of March into April. Among working adults, we observed worsening in terms of indicators for mental health,” he said.
He further explained that depression-related content in Michigan became more prevalent, which highlights the financial impact on businesses, government response, and documented shortages in medical supplies, such as ventilators, drugs (e.g., chloroquine, hydroxychloroquine), and personal protective equipment (PPE) for medical professionals.
Sheth noted significant correlation between social media posts and mental health concerns in Wyoming, Alaska, Washington, and Idaho.
Findings from other states include:
- Arizona: Younger population maintained much better mental health compared to the adult working population.
- Georgia: The young population has largely remained vulnerable and highly affected in their mental health, while the older working population improved over time.
- Iowa: Adult population improved their mental health conditions over time, while the younger population worsened.
- Wisconsin: Working population showed a significant decline in mental health indicators while the young population deteriorated more significantly.
“The reasons for these differences are not yet well understood. Some of it is circumstantial. Some of it may be demographic. Some of it may be related to differential access to mental health treatment,” Sheth said.
The fact that young people are having a hard time in most states except Arizona may have something to do with sunlight, Landau said.
“Speaking as a person living in the Northeast, I know my mood is vastly improved when I can get outside and get physical activity, a known buffer to depression. In Arizona, young people have the time and ability to do this,” she said.
Which posts are signs that someone is struggling?
Sheth uses a tool called a knowledge graph to associate the language people use with relevant medical knowledge in mental health and addiction.
This allows him to filter different ways a user could talk about mental health concepts, often in an indirect way.
Examples of tweets might include:
- “All the things are being shut down by #Covid19 but my anxiety & depression.”
- “You believe I have any pleasure in this chaos? Jeez. I’ve been despairing for 2 months.”
- “A feeling of hopelessness. Seems I am in a dark age. #coronavirus #COVID19
- “Self-isolated for two weeks and depression becoming unbearable. This coronavirus is worsening my anxiety a lot and I am terrified.”
Landau said other posts and tweets that contain words or phrases like the following may be an indication of mental health concerns.