Continuing the dialogue

Categories: About

DBPosterCan a fiction based upon a hoax tell us anything about who we are? “Spinning Into Butter” is a controversial and award-winning play, inspired by a racial incident that occurred while playwright Rebecca Gilman was a student at Middlebury in the early ’80s. On April 9th a multi-racial cast presented scenes from “Spinning Into Butter,” interspersed with audience reactions, to explore the script, its source material, and how we experience and respond to race at Middlebury in 2010.

After the play, audience members were asked to write a question they were left with on the back of their programme. We collected these questions and posted them here. Please share your perspective on these issues.

Watch the performance

If Patrick were the one writing the notes, would the response be different?

Categories: Uncategorized

The victim/perpetrator incites a series of internal dialogues that would have otherwise gone undiscussed and unchallenged. While his behaviors are clearly (or perhaps not so clearly) motivated by a deeply distraught mentality, it is interesting to expound upon what drives such incentive. In the same manner that a woman who has never been raped accuses one of raping her undermines the experiences of those who have actually experienced it, how also do such actions present deeply subversive & internal manifestations of self hate as agency.

With the example of Patrick, the neorican, and his experiences w/ racism, though not directly violent – are still acts of racism. If Patrick were the one writing the notes, would the response be different?

While the victim/perpetrator behaved in a way that undermined the experiences of Patrick & others & completely disrupt a continued & ligitimate conversation / action – are his intentions valid?

I would like to see more from the aspect of the “others” or minorities

Categories: Uncategorized

I like that the piece initiates, or at least introduces the opportunity to initiate a dicussion about inter-racial relations/dynamics, however I would like to see more from the aspect of the “others” or minorities within the larger discussion. I’m saying that I appreciated the candidness of the caucasian participants in this piece.

I think the most anti-racist acts are admittances.

Categories: Uncategorized

Thank you for putting this together. In our small groups, one of the questions was about whether or not we noticed trends of hypocrisy in the play or in Middlebury as is.

One of the biggest contradictions I feel exists in the running of a college is its split identity between being a business and a living, breathing place made for and by students. I empathize with administrators who are constantly maneuvering through social, emotional, race + class tensions in our system. A college has an image to uphold, but I also think that image can be activism. I think the most anti-racist acts are admittances.

How do we balance image and reality, the line between learning institution + business?

I’m ashamed that I haven’t been pro-active in being anti-racist.

Categories: Uncategorized

I’m ashamed that I haven’t been pro-active in being anti-racist. It’s not enough to be a “nice person,” I need to be an activist. This performance really hit home & made me realize this. It made me feel guilty of my inaction. So thank you for waking me up from my comfortable life.

-Dilanthi Ranaweera

p.s. could you pls give this back to me so I can paste it somewhere where I will see it everyday to remind me that I can no longer wait or put social justice on hold.

[on campus address: Admissions Office]

Translating less direct racist reveals the more poignant manifestation of racism

Categories: Uncategorized

It seems to me that the event of a black student taking the initiative to translate the seemingly less direct racism, stemming from more apathetic simplification than bigotry, to a clear display of active bigotry, reveals the more poignant manifestation of racism, as it effects people’s lives.

What kind of training program would work for faculty?

Categories: Uncategorized

What kind of training program would work for faculty? What would give them the opportunity and support to grow and change, therefore serve students better? An opportunity like Sarah needed. Nobody can work through a racist cultural upbringing alone and nobody is exempt.

“Sometimes it falls upon a generation to be great. We can be that great generation.”

Categories: Uncategorized

“Sometimes it falls upon a generation to be great. We can be that great generation.”

What is the definition of or requirement for a ‘non-racist’?

Categories: Uncategorized

What is the definition of or requirement for a ‘non-racist’? If you are not racist what are you – is there a word which isn’t a negative?

How can we hold discussions about race w/o them becoming repetitive?

Categories: Uncategorized

Is Sara as representative of our administration / white people in general as she was presented?

How can we hold dicussions about race @ Midd w/o them becoming repetitive, as they often do? Or is it true that meaningful dialogues are an oxymoron and not to the point?

Tricky dichotomies:

institution v. progression

administration v. education

anti-racist v. true understanding

It gets tiring to feel like we are always failing

Categories: Uncategorized

I identified w/ Dean Sarah’s feeling of abject failure. It gets tiring to feel like we (faculty + administrators) are always failing to make this place as racially diverse + as livable + tolerable for all students as it should be. And good, well-intentioned efforts do continue to fail.

The incident was wrong, but it opened up an issue

Categories: Uncategorized

The incident at Middlebury College in 1984 involving a student who victimized himself by posting racial slurs on his door was very wrong, but it had opened up an issue that might have never been addressed till a much later date.

Is ignorance racism?

Categories: Uncategorized

Is ignorance racism?

Were Grace’s actions so bad?

Categories: Uncategorized

Were Grace’s actions so bad? Were there benefits? What were they?

Stereotyping becomes racism

Categories: Uncategorized

“Stereotyping becomes racism when in the face of proof, one still decides to accept society’s truth.”

Is there such a thing as unintentional racism?

Categories: Uncategorized

Is there such a thing as unintentional racism? If it was unintentional, it was ignorance, not racism.

White people shouldn’t feel guilty

Categories: Uncategorized

White people shouldn’t feel guilty about how racism has been damaging in the past if they have done nothing to personally make it worse, but they should be aware that lack of knowledge & not working toward fixing the problem is (almost) as damaging as outwardly supporting racism.

A few things that stood out to me

Categories: Uncategorized

A few things that stood out to me

  • I didn’t understand why the college didn’t consider hiring a person of color for the “minority student liaison”
  • Even more disturbing… why the person who held that position didn’t realize that was part of her job description. It makes me wonder what the true purpose / intention of the college is – to make the students of color feel comfortable in a “Middlebury-like” environment, to up the diversity. Why?

let us step forward and reflect

Categories: Uncategorized

no the student did not do it

it was the college

no the college did not do it

we all did

we forgot that we like all others

we indeed must critically self reflect

our intentions

our bias

our dreams

our everything

yes it is we

let us not retreat in guilt

let us step forward and reflect

Positive discrimination is a disguised form of racism

Categories: Uncategorized

Positive discrimination is a disguised form of racism as it does consider a part of the population of a country as different from the rest.

Self-racism is perhaps the most harmful racism

Categories: Uncategorized

I don’t like how it was discussed as being a now unracist event because it was a hoax. Self-racism even when not intended is perhaps the most harmful racism. Awareness is good & all through the arts (such as this) but there will never be true peace till we learn to forget about the issues & enjoy¬† as well. I know ‘minorities’ on campus that don’t see themselves as ‘minorities’ & that’s good, until he’s forced to show concern for his race, & then have to think himself as a minority.

There seems to be an extreme focus on political correctness

Categories: Uncategorized

There seems to be an extreme focus on political correctness which only hinders discussion – it would be very beneficial if everyone said how they felt without worrying overly about the term “African American” versus “black” versus “people of colour.” This is still very relevant, but I think that this has a strong relation to the issue of gay rights and the homophobia among Middlebury sports teams.

Race is a constant entity in the mind

Categories: Uncategorized

Well, every interaction – ever if there aren’t any words shared – are based on how we perceive others as well as ourselves. Because most people are capable of visually perceiving others, race is a constant entity in their mind – subconsciously at least. Therefore, people are always going to have a hint of a prejudice or racist thought when interacting.

Also, I wonder why did the kid write the note on his door himself… maybe to bring the concept of race up in a dominant “white” campus.

Everybody’s racist.

Categories: Uncategorized

Everybody’s racist. Admitting it gives you hope. Being wary of racism – tiring when you’re tired, you give in. There must be some way to address racism past having everybody tirelessly watching out for it. How do you “work to fix the racism problem?”

Everyone can discriminate, and everyone can be discriminated against.

Categories: Uncategorized

Everyone can discriminate, and everyone can be discriminated against. It is a vicious and out of control cycle that is difficult but not impossible to break. Whether or not we discriminate or are discriminated against we each have the choice of how to act and react. It is only in taking responsibility for our feelings that we will find not only tolerance but unity.

There’s something human about being racist

Categories: Uncategorized

There’s something human about being racist but not until we (both parties, colored and non-colored) are willing or feel comfortable enough to confront each other, to criticize each other, and to accuse each other, I think, will anything change.

I am reconsidering my contempt for the play.

Categories: Uncategorized

Well done – well acted – good selection of scenes to dramatize. I have read the whole play + despaired at the depictions of the (white) adults (Deans – faculty). I am reconsidering my contempt for the play. It is a far cry from what actually happened – and is an effective presentation of well-intentioned or unintentional racism.

KL

To White America

Categories: Uncategorized

To White America- if you have been programmed since birth by the media, your family, your friends, your schools, your churches and places of worship, your work and your government, your national myths and your culture to be racist, to harbor racist stereotypes and racist sentiments against people of color, how can we, those you despise and discriminate against, deprogram you to see us as individuals, as human beings? The programming has been strong enough that even we have internalized the racism at times, but we cannot save you from yourselves. We have tried, but ultimately it is you who has to confront your own demons. When you, White America, are ready to have an honest conversation with yourself and reflect upon the ways you are racist, or at the very least maintain a racist paradigm, then we will be ready to work and talk with you about creating a truly non-oppressive society. We will be waiting.

– Bobby Joe Smith III

What was Grayce’s motivation?

Categories: Uncategorized

What was Grayce’s motivation?

How is it ‘all over’?

Categories: Uncategorized

How is it ‘all over’ just because he admitted that he’d written the notes himself?

– In reaction to Erica Wonnacott’s statement “thank god it’s all over”

The last article read by Luis angered me.

Categories: Uncategorized

The last article read by Luis angered me. The Dean (Wonnacott) explained the student’s actions (black student who wrote himself racist notes) on his “problems”. Though the student was wrong in doing this, why didn’t Midd (as an institution) take into account why the student was pushed to do such a thing – what caused these feelings? Why was all responsibility + accountability taken away from the institution when this was obviously an issue somehow caused by racial relations on campus?

Great job, everyone! Shipuia ’12

How to break out of the cycle of talking past each other?

Categories: Uncategorized

How to break out of the cycle of talking past each other?

We need engaged discussions

Categories: Uncategorized

We need engaged discussions on race, class, gender, and ethnicity in all of our classes and a commitment from all members of the College to eradicate racism from our community

How do we make progress on RACE problems

Categories: Uncategorized

How do we make progress on RACE problems

1. charismatic leaders who call upon us see others in a way we haven’t

2. artistic works that challenge the paradigm in which racism exists

3. sharing our work and our lives with others so that we see beyond the racial and cultural impasse to our shared humanity

If we know what’s not the answer, how will we know what is?

Categories: Uncategorized

If we know what’s not the answer, how will we know what is?

What can I do?

Categories: Uncategorized

What can I do? How can I speak about race without inhibition? Without feeling or being perceived as patronizing? Without acting selfishly? (Bulleted response, please.)

Is the American experience haunted by a legacy of discrimination?

Categories: Uncategorized

Is the American experience haunted by a legacy of discrimination unsettled – not brought to closure?

How much of what we do is based on a world we think we live in?

Categories: Uncategorized

With the problem of race, how much of what we do is based on a world we think we live in – an illusion – versus the world that is actually there?

What could have been in place to prevent a situation like this?

Categories: Uncategorized

I found myself wondering what could have been in place to prevent a situation like this from occurring.

I was really drawn by the fact that the actors kept changing

Categories: Uncategorized

I was really drawn by the fact that the actors kept changing in the roles of the administration – leaving Patrick the only one with a physical identity

It’s not over

Categories: Uncategorized

It’s not over

Grayce’s thoughts are shared

He may’ve wrote it but that doesn’t mean he was the only one thinking it

How can I deal with being criticized for doing something patronizing or offensive?

Categories: Uncategorized

How can I learn to LISTEN and not react to get defensive? How can I not be a Sarah? Can there be any exceptions to those “rules”? (I know better than to think there are rules that can be put on a bulleted list, but I can’t think of a better word to use.) How can I start working with people rather than working for them?

I liked the choice to have the actors switch for all characters but Patrick.

Categories: Uncategorized

I liked the choice to have the actors switch for all characters but Patrick. This disconnected race & gender from these characters, allowing us – the audience – to place ourselves in their shoes & question what we would do in that case.

It’s going to keep being hard for a long time.

Categories: Uncategorized

It’s going to keep being hard for a long time.

“Thank God it’s over”

Categories: Uncategorized

“Thank God it’s over”. But it isn’t. The note may have been a fraud, but the racism is real.

I enjoyed the choice of having ppl signify their ‘race’ by using shirt color.

Categories: Uncategorized

I enjoyed the choice of having ppl signify their ‘race’ by using shirt color. It asked the audience if they could blur lines (what they saw vs what they were being asked to recognize). And I think it was interesting that they only asked us to blur race (not sex, etc.).

What action needs to happen?

Categories: Uncategorized

Many students say that there is a lot of talk + no action on campus. What action needs to happen? What needs to happen to make Midd a better place for people of color on campus?

– MR class of ’08