Challenging the Wilderness Ideal

Ansel Adams (1902-1984), Mount Williamson, Sierra Nevada, from Manzanar, California, 1944, gelatin silver print. Middlebury College Museum of Art. Purchase with funds provided by the Electra Havemeyer Webb Memorial Fund and the Christian A. Johnson Memorial Art Acquisition Fund, 2003.006. Reproduced with permission from The Ansel Adams Publishing Rights Trust. All rights reserved.

In 1964, the United States Congress passed the Wilderness Act, which established a national wilderness preservation system composed of federally owned areas designated by Congress as “wilderness areas.” The Act defined wilderness as “an area where the earth and its community of life are untrammeled by man, where man himself is a visitor who does not remain.” With panoramas of glowing mountain ranges and thundering waterfalls devoid of any human presence, the photographs of Ansel Adams have come to represent the epitome of wilderness imagery.

By the early 1970s, however, a younger generation of photographers that included Robert Adams (no relation), Frank Gohlke, Joe Deal, Lewis Baltz and others began to take issue with this notion of nature. Deriding Ansel Adams’ views of Yosemite as “sappy” (Deal’s word) and Romantic, they photographed grain elevators, suburban housing developments at the base of mountain ranges, urban architecture and parking lots featured in the New Topographics exhibition at the George Eastman House in 1975.

In more recent decades, scholars have re-evaluated the very notion of wilderness, arguing that the concept of uninhabited, pristine nature itself is a complex cultural construction that ignores the native peoples who had lived on “wilderness” lands for centuries, as well as privileging human beings over other forms of life. Moreover, critics argue that fetishizing distant wild locales absolves us of concern for places and marginalized people  closer to home. As historian William Cronon wrote in 1995, “wilderness embodies a dualistic vision in which the human is entirely outside the natural,” adding “to the extent that we live in an urban-industrial civilization but at the same time pretend to ourselves that our real home is in the wilderness, to just that extent we give ourselves permission to evade responsibility for the lives we actually lead.”[footnote]William Cronon, “The Trouble with Wilderness,” in Carolyn Merchant, Major Problems in American Environmental History, 2nd ed. (Boston and New York: Houghton Mifflin Company, 2005), 385-86.[/footnote]

screen-shot-2016-12-01-at-9-00-10-am
George Osodi, Oil Spill Near Farm Land Ogoni, 2007, digital ink print. Middlebury College Museum of Art. Purchase with funds provided by the Foster Family Art Acquisition Fund, 2012.028. By permission of George Osodi c/o Z Photographic Ltd.

A number of photographers working today who are represented in this exhibition, including Nigerian photographer George Osodi, have replaced the idealized wilderness with the realities of environmental degradation. While earlier photographers such as Ansel Adams used their work to argue for wilderness conservation, contemporary photographers like Osodi document issues confronting us directly.

What is an Archival Inkjet Print?

Digital photographs are images made from a digital file using a printer that applies very fine drop of ink on paper. As digital technology was developed in the early twentieth century, the question of print stability have led to the development of increasingly stable inks and papers. Materials are subjected to rigorous accelerated again tests to determine how long a photographs will last without significant fading. Today there are many options of digital rag papers and inks that are expected to last more than a century if prints are properly stored and exhibited. The terms “Archival Pigment Print” and “Giclée Print” are also used for such prints. The longevity rates of many pigment prints are calculated at over 100 years, depending on the paper used. As an ink-based process, modern digital printing has more in common with late nineteenth-century photogravures than with chromogenic prints made throughout the twentieth century.

 

What is a Daguerreotype?

babbittThe daguerreotype process, named for its French inventor, Louis Jacques Mandé Daguerre, was one of the first forms of photography. Images were exposed in-camera on sensitized metal plates coated with a thin layer of highly-polished silver, then developed, fixed, and mounted in protective cases. Since no negatives were used, daguerreotypes are one-of-a-kind images.

Between 1839 and the early 1850s, the heyday of the medium, daguerreotypes were used primarily to make studio portraits. Sitters posed with their heads held still by metal braces and their hands perched on the arms of chairs or holding objects like books. Because of the bulky equipment, complicated process, and long exposure times, outdoor scenes were much less common. Despite the difficulty of viewing an image on a mirrored surface, daguerreotypes were valued for their amazing detail.

What is an albumen print?

old-trapperscreen-shot-2016-12-02-at-11-23-30-amIn 1839, the invention of photo very different photographic processes was announced to the world. The daguerreotype, invented by Louis Jacques Mandé Daguerre, was a unique image on a metal plate coated with mirrored silver. Although the process was capable of rendering precise detail, the metal surface and lack of negative to make prints limited it as a practical photographic process. The calotype, perfected by William Henry Fox Talbot, was a negative/positive process that produced multiple prints on paper, but the paper negatives used resulted in fuzzy prints lacking fine detail.

In 1851, the wet-plate collodion process was developed. It combined aspects of both the daguerreotype and the calotype. Light sensitive chemicals suspended in sticky collodion could be poured on metal plates to produce single tintypes, or on glass to produce negatives from which prints could be made. The collodion was only light sensitive while wet, which required the exposing and developing to happen within about a ten-minute period. Prints made from glass negatives had the fine detail of a daguerreotype, as well as the calotype’s potential for multiple prints. During the second half of the nineteenth century, photographic paper was coated with egg whites to bind photographic chemicals to the paper. Durable prints could be made in large numbers, although the thin paper’s tendency to curl required prints to be mounted to a cardboard backing. Because the chemicals used in making wet-plate collodion negatives were sensitive only to blue light, a sky with clouds was almost impossible to photograph. Landscape photographers often worked around this limitation by using multiple negatives to make a single print – one exposed for the land and another for the sky.

Photographing Yosemite

muybridge
Eadweard Muybridge, Loya, Valley of Yosemite, c. 1872. Albumen print, Middlebury College Museum of Art, purchase with funds provided by the Friends of Art Acquisition Fund. 1998.030

screen-shot-2016-12-02-at-11-23-30-amBefore the first non-native people entered Yosemite Valley in 1849, it was home to a Native American tribe known as the Ahwahneechee, who lived in the region for over 3000 years. In the mid-nineteenth century, the United States army drove them out of what we now call Yosemite National Park. One of the first white settlers to make his home in the valley was Galen Clark. Clark established a hotel for visitors in the Mariposa Grove, home to the Giant Sequoia trees.

In 1861 the most important early photographer to visit the Yosemite region, Carleton Watkins, had a mammoth camera constructed to hold 18 x 22 inch glass plate negatives. Entering the valley with a twelve-mule pack train, he not only brought his camera and glass plates but also chemicals, a portable darkroom, and other equipment, including a camera designed to take small paired photographs called stereographs. These would be viewed through a special stereoscope that would merge the two images into one with the illusion of three-dimensional depth. Together with his mammoth plate photographs, Watkins’ stereographs helped raise public awareness about the wonders of Yosemite Valley.

Watkins returned multiple times to the valley in 1861, and again in 1865 and 1866 while working for the California State Geological Survey. Although his stereographs only provided Anglicized names for landscape features, his mammoth plate photographs frequently gave both the Ahwahneechee and the English versions of places with titles such as Piwyac, the Vernal Fall and Pompompasos, the Three Brothers.

Partly on the evidence of Watkins’ extraordinary photographs, in 1864 Abraham Lincoln signed a bill declaring the valley protected, paving the way for the national Parks system. Other photographers soon made their way to Yosemite. Eadweard Muybridge, better known for his studies of human and animal locomotion, photographed the region in 1867 and again in 1872. Using the long exposures required by the technology of the day, early photographers pictured rivers as smooth surfaces and waterfalls and blurred flowing water.

In 1890, an act of Congress created Yosemite National Park. With the completion of the Yosemite Valley Railroad in 1907, tourists began visiting the area in droves. Among them was the fourteen-year-old Ansel Adams, who roamed the valley taking snapshots with a Kodak box camera. In 1927, Adams would produce his first important series of Yosemite photographs, Parmelian Prints of the High Sierras. Adams would continue to photograph Yosemite for the rest of his career, producing the iconic wilderness photographs that established his reputation as the best-known American landscape photographer of the twentieth century.

What is a Chromogenic Print?

Also called dye coupler prints and “type-C prints (if made from a negative) or type-R prints (if made from a transparency),” chromogenic prints form the majority of color prints made after their introduction in 1936 and before advent of digital ink-based printing. The term “chrome” refers to the origin of the photograph in a slide or transparency. Some chromogenic prints produced today are made from scanned slides or transparency that are then printed digitally. Commercially manufactured paper coated with emulsions containing colored dyes enabled photographers to choose from a wide range of surfaces, ranging form matte to ultra-glossy. Easier and less costly to produce than the dye-transfer process, some chromogenic prints lack the color stability of dye-transfer prints or archival digital papers and inks used today and are prone to color fading.

What is a photogravure?

Photogravure is a photomechanical process that combines photography and etching to make ink-based photographic prints. A photograph is etched onto a copper place that is then inked. A dampened sheet of paper is placed on top of the inked plate, which is then run through an etching press. Popular with Pictorialist photographers who wanted to raise the status of photography to fine art at the end of the nineteenth century, in the early twentieth century photogravure was popularized by Alfred Stieglitz, who included finely made photogravures in his publication Camera Work. Unlike photomechanical processes such as half-tone that rely upon dot patterns to reproduce an image, photogravure produces a finely-nuanced continuous tone image. Color effects can be achieved through the use of tinted inks.

Kirsten Hoving, Coma Berenices, 2010. Photogravure print
Kirsten Hoving, Coma Berenices, 2010. Photogravure plate

 

What is a Photogravure?

Photogravure is a photomechanical process that combines photography and etching to make ink-based photographic prints. A photograph is etched onto a copper place that is then inked. A dampened sheet of paper is placed on top of the inked plate, which is then run through an etching press. Popular with Pictorialist photographers who wanted to raise the status of photography to fine art at the end of the nineteenth century, in the early twentieth century photogravure was popularized by Alfred Stieglitz, who included finely made photogravures in his publication Camera Work. Unlike photomechanical processes such as half-tone that rely upon dot patterns to reproduce an image, photogravure produces a finely-nuanced continuous tone image. Color effects can be achieved through the use of tinted inks.

 

 

 

Robert Adams, Clatsop County, Oregon, 1999-2003

Robert Adams (1937 – ), Clatsop County, Oregon, from Turning Back, A Photographic Journal of Re-exploration, 1999-2003, gelatin silver print. Middlebury College Museum of Art. Purchase with funds provided by Kathy and Richard S. Fuld, Jr. 2006.026.091. © Robert Adams, courtesy Fraenkel Gallery, San Francisco

A forest is felled, with stumps and roots and nature’s rubble littering the ground. A few distant trees stand like parentheses on the edges, as the hill rises to meet the sky. A deep sense of loss pervades the image, as we confront the aftermath of industrial forestry in Clatsop County, Oregon.

In 2006, through a generous gift, the Middlebury College Museum of Art acquired a complete set of Robert Adams’ photographic essay, Turning Back, A Photographic Journal of Re-Exploration, comprising 164 photographs on the theme of deforestation. In response to the bicentennial of the Lewis and Clark expedition, Adams turned back from the Pacific Ocean and photographed what is left of the vast forest the explorers encountered two centuries earlier.

Such are the ravages of clear cut logging. As new trees fill in, they are the same age, and the forest’s ancient markers of time are eradicated. Trees no longer hold water, nutrients are leached from eroded soil, and undergrowth and habitats are destroyed. Given the current rate of deforestation, the world’s rainforests could disappear completely in a hundred years.

Prior to the arrival of European-Americans, about half of the United States was forest. Adams observes, “The importance of what’s going on in terms of clear-cutting is that there is no indication that this can go on forever. If you turn the globe, you see a history of deforestation that changed societies and from which there has not been, in many cases, a complete recovery—in some cases, no recovery at all. The nub of it is that if you keep cutting (and bear in mind that the cutting now is sustained by the use of artificial herbicides and fertilizers), the soil is eroded more and more. It’s a major contributor to global warming.”[footnote]Interview with Robert Adams: “Turning Back,” Art 21 online magazine. http://www.art21.org/texts/robert-adams/interview-robert-adams-turning-back, accessed January 4, 2017.[/footnote]

Adams situates clear cutting within larger social and political contexts, ironically noting that taxes from industrial forestry are used fund schools and, the argument goes, benefit children. Adams counters, “I think it’s also a terrible example of violence and heedlessness to offer to each new generation. If you don’t care about what your grandchildren and their children are going to inherit, what do you care about?”[footnote]Interview with Robert Adams: “Turning Back,” Art 21 online magazine. http://www.art21.org/texts/robert-adams/interview-robert-adams-turning-back, accessed January 4, 2017.[/footnote]

Listen as professor of Biology and Environmental Studies, Steve Trombulak, discusses the pros and cons of clear cutting. And scroll down to hear Middlebury student Tevan Goldberg interpret the photograph with music: