Louise Erdrich, Future Home of the Living God, 2017
Analysis by Elly Tuffy, Claire Miller, and Sodoba Faizi
New York: Harper Collins, 2017.
Brief Summary
Cedar Songmaker is pregnant, and the end of the world has begun. Evolution unexplainably began reversing, and scientists are scrambling to find out why. The government begins detaining all pregnant women in an attempt to control reproduction and ensure the continuation of the human race. With the help of her adopted and biological Ojibwe family, Cedar attempts to avoid the authorities and have a future with her baby. The story, written as journal entries to Cedar’s unborn child, is set in the near future where climate change has continued to warm the world and now the ultimate environmental chaos has begun.
Timeline of the Imagined Future
Before the crisis:
Cedar is a 26 year-old indigenous woman living in South Minneapolis, Minnesota. She was raised by her adoptive parents, Sera and Glen. Since finding out she is pregnant, she has decided to reconnect with her biological Ojibwe family. She meets and develops a relationship with her biological family, the Potts, who live on the reservation. The world is much warmer than we know it know, with 90ºF being a cool day in Minnesota.
The crisis begins:
Evolution reverses – As she is returning from the reservation, scientists have discovered that evolution is reversing, but they do not know why. Prehistoric species like sabertooth cats have been sighted wandering neighborhoods. Chaos breaks out over this profound existential and biological crisis. There is concern that the next generation will turn out to be Neanderthals instead of humans.
Government Control – The government responds by imposing martial law on the population and increasing surveillance. All pregnant women are told to turn themselves in to hospitals, and those that do not come forward are forcibly detained. Cedar is among the women who initially hides from the government, until her boyfriend Phil is tortured to give up her location.
Societal Breakdown – All the basic services like electricity and television cease working. Money loses its value as people barter for goods scare food and medical supplies. The Postal Service becomes the only reliable means of communication.
Hospital Prisons – Pregnant women are brought to be monitored at government run centers. Their babies are taken from them, and many women die in child birth. Cedar, like many other women, is brought to one of these hospitals where she is drugged and imprisoned. Cedar was lucky enough to escape with the help of her hospital roommate, Tia Jackson, and her mother Sera.
Resistance begins – Groups form to aid pregnant women, establishing underground safe houses. The goal is to eventually smuggle pregnant women to Canada.
The Escape – After escaping the hospital, Tia goes into labor. Her baby ends up being stillborn. Although the outcome is devastating, without a child Tia is able to return to her husband and a “normal” life without a newborn to worry about and protect. Her ability to return to life highlights the extreme oppression facing pregnant women.
The Challenge in Saving Pregnant Women – Cedar travels back through safe houses until she can reach the Ojibwe reservation. She feels safe surrounded by her family, but she still can’t venture outside for fear of being sighted by government surveillance. Feeling trapped in the house on the reservation, Cedar attempts to go pray at a statue on the reservation. However, she gets abducted by strangers and turned into the authorities for a reward.
Reproduction in a new era – Cedar gets taken to a prison where the government is forcing women to carry babies. Here Cedar gives birth to her baby but never gets to meet them. Other women are brought into the prison for committing crimes and are forcibly implanted with embryos. The novel ends with Ceder trapped in a prison and the readers understanding that she will probably be forced to carry more babies until she ultimately dies.
Climate Change Continues – Cedar fantasizes if her child will ever see snow, or if snow is simply a distant memory. It is clear that humans have done nothing to stop global warming, and they are now thoroughly preoccupied with the reversal of evolution.
Characters
Cedar Hawk Songmaker: devotedly Catholic, writes a Catholic magazine called Zeal, gets pregnant at 26 and is excited at the prospect of having a baby. Reunites with her Ojibwe biological family soon after finding out she’s pregnant.
Sera Songmaker: The adoptive mother of Cedar. Spends her time throughout the book rescuing Cedar from the prison-like hospitals. She is very resourceful but also very worried about her pregnant daughter.
Glen Songmaker: The adoptive (and later revealed biological) father of Cedar. Before evolution began to reverse he was an environmental lawyer, and after he spent time looking for ways for Cedar to get to safety.
Sweetie (Mary Potts): The biological mother of Cedar who is introduced at the beginning of the novel. She wants to befriend Cedar, but she is also partially responsible for Cedar being found and sent back to the government.
Eddy: The stepfather of Cedar and husband of Sweetie. He is writing a book that will never end to document reasons to live. He becomes head of the Tribal Council post-reversal of evolution and is focused on reclaiming their tribe’s territory.
Little Mary: The biological sister of Cedar. Seen as a casualty of reservation life as she struggles with drug addiction.
Mary Potts Senior: The biological grandmother of Cedar. She is seen as wise and knowing. Throughout the book Cedar returns to her for advice on their family and on the birth of her future child.
Phil: shelters 3 pregnant women in the basement of church while taking care of Cedar. Gets caught by police and tortured to give up names of pregnant women. Sees the opportunity of Cedar having a healthy baby as a way to become a new social elite.
Tia Jackson: A pregnant woman whom Cedar shares a room with at the hospital prison. They work together to break out with the help of Cedars’s mom, Sera. When Tia eventually gives birth, her baby is stillborn. With no baby to hide, she is able to go back to her previous life and rejoin her husband.
Imagined Human Actions and “Solutions”
Government Control of Reproduction
Scientists are racing to understand how evolution is reversing and its possible ramifications. There is a fear that the next generation may not have the capacity for speech or may be Neanderthals instead of humans. To address the crisis, the government institutes a harsh and strictly controlled reproduction program. The Patriot Act was expanded so the government could seize medical records and determine the identities of pregnant women across the country. Pregnant women are encouraged to turn themselves in so they can stay at government-run hospitals. These hospitals are more like prisons where women cannot choose to leave. To hold all the pregnant women, prisons are emptied and turned into “hospitals.” The prisoners who originally occupied the prisons are killed or trained to hunt down pregnant women.
As time passes, the government becomes increasingly militant in its reproduction program. Community members are offered rewards to bring in pregnant women. A womb draft is established where women of child-bearing age can be conscripted to be implanted with a random frozen embryo using IVF. The government frames pregnant women into martyrs as they exploit them to the point of death in efforts to continue the human race as we know it.
Technology Responses
Throughout the book, modern technology slowly begins to vanish as the world dissolves into chaos. When the news of evolution reversing breaks, communities use television and radios to stay updated. Quickly, the available media becomes propaganda under the control of the government. Eventually, television and radio stop working all together, and there is almost no way to get reliable news. People have to depend on the postal service to communicate over any distance. While modern communication technology fails for the average citizen, the government utilizes more advanced surveillance technology. New devices called Listeners or Ears, are tiny ear-shaped devices that float through the air, no bigger than a seed. Some of them are even transparent. These are used to listen in on the population and catch pregnant women or those helping them.
Additionally, IVF technology comes under the control of the government. They take all frozen embryos from before the time of evolution reversing and begin implanting them in women who have been arrested or selected through the womb draft. Technology and the controlling of reproduction become part of the same human response.
Growth of religion in a time of chaos
The scientifically unexplainable phenomenon of evolution reversing inspired a mass turn to religion for explanation and solace. Glen, for example, sees the reversal of evolution as Mother Nature’s retribution for all the damage humans have done. A variety of Christian movements see it as God reversing creation, which could only mean the end of the world. The title of the book, “Future Home of the Living God,” invokes this sentiment that the return of God will be the end of humanity. As people turn to religion to process the situation, streets are renamed to bible verses. The statue of Saint Kateri on the Ojibwe reservation becomes a site of pilgrimage for those seeking a connection to God during a time of chaos.
Portrayal of Heroes and Villains
Throughout the novel, the most prevalent “heroes” are Sera Songmaker and Eddy, both of whom hold parental roles in the plot. The two adults provide Cedar with reassurance and safety as the world descends into chaos. Sera is portrayed as a loving mother who has her faults but simply wants the best for her child. When Sera meets Cedar’s biological parents, instead of looking down on them, she befriends them and tries to understand their world. When Cedar is taken to the hospital, Sera is the one who finds a way to get a job as a nurse and help Cedar and Tia escape. Sera always tries to keep Cedar safe. Similarly, Eddy plays a fatherly role in Cedar’s life, even though they just recently met. Eddy is the first person that Cedar tells about her pregnancy. He is the one who sends notes to her when she is in the hospital with codes on when to escape. Eddy holds further hero power because he also is elected leader of the Ojibwe reservation and begins to buy back land for the tribe.
The main villains in the novel are the government, scientists, and the nurses who are imprisoning pregnant women in hospitals or prisons. The government and its scientists are the biggest villains in Cedar’s story as they are the ones who made the call to round up all the pregnant women and experiment on the babies. The villains in Cedar’s day-to-day life are the nurses in the hospital, specifically Orielee. While other nurses like The Slider and Geri make Cedar’s life difficult, Orielee lulls Cedar into a sense of false friendship and kindness just to trick her into trusting her.
Other characters are neither heroes nor villains but instead carry a grey ethical role in the novel. Phil, Cedar’s boyfriend can be considered one of these people. For the first part of the book, Phil seems to be a hero, as he does everything in his power to keep Cedar hidden and safe from the authorities. However, later it is revealed that Phil was caught and tortured into revealing where Cedar was hiding, causing her to be taken by the government. When Phil and Cedar are reunited, Phil tries to get Cedar to run away with him. He explains that Cedar might be carrying one of the original babies that wasn’t impacted by the backward evolution, which makes her special. He says that they could be very powerful in this new world. Phil represents the human that is corrupted by the world descending into chaos. His intentions are good, however, by the end of the book he is only thinking about how to help himself. We can see this similar seemingly selfish motivation in other characters in the book. For example, the people who kidnapped Cedar and turned her into the government needed the money reward to feed their family. In a world where everything is falling apart, people are pushed to do things they would not have done before.
American Environmental Thought & Climate Themes
Myth of the “Ecological Indian”
Cedar Songmaker grew up with her adoptive white parents who treated her like an “Indian princess”. When she was young, Cedar was seen by her peers as being special and connected to nature due to her Native heritage. Her parents helped her embrace this native image by always keeping her hair in braids. It took her going to college and meeting other Natives to realize it was a constructed image of indigeneity and she didn’t have a connection with her native roots. She was also disappointed to learn that her biological family did not fit the stereotype of an indigenous family. Instead, her given name was Mary Potts, and her biological family, the Potts, owned a gas station on the reservation.
Additionally, Phil once told Cedar that she reminded him of the Land O’ Lakes Butter Maiden, on the logo of the one-pound butter box. She was a voluptuous Native girl kneeling in nature representing a constant in his childhood. Phil fetishized her as an exotic Native woman who was connected with nature in the way that he wanted to be. These two examples of white characters placing their assumptions of Native people on Cedar represent the prevalent theme of the “Ecological Indian” in American history. The myth that indigenous people are inherently more connected to the environment t has been common in media for decades, however, it holds little truth. Erdrich uses her white characters to critique these assumptions and show how wrong they can be.
Home and Environment
The environment plays a role in this novel as something safe and sacred that can protect Cedar and her family. In a way, it is romanticized as something that the pregnant woman can’t have because they are hiding from the authorities/people in charge. Multiple times Cedar expresses the want to venture outside after being trapped indoors for so long. These sentiments are expressed when she is hiding in her home and when she is locked in the hospital room. This theme is reflected throughout American literature in writings about the wilderness and the environment being the “real home”. Wealthy white men venture into the jungle to prove themselves worthy and women preach back to the land practices. Although this is a minor theme throughout the book, it feels important to mention that the lack of involvement in the environment is trying to portray something bigger.
Evolution Reverses
The end-of-the-world premise of this book is that evolution is reversing. Children are not born with the same genetic abilities and people are concerned about the uncertainty of the future. People question whether children born now will speak, read, or write. They wonder how far back evolution will shift. Since the novel is written from Cedar’s perspective, the readers don’t know the scientific details about the crisis since the government is keeping the public in the dark. From Cedar’s point of view, it seems like the government also doesn’t know what’s going on.
Although this is never explicitly stated, climate change and a warming planet may be the cause of evolution reversing. In addition to children being born differently, people were spotting ancient animals around the country. It is clear to the reader that things are mutating and shifting, which may have to do with the amount of change that the Earth is going through. The last journal entry in the book is written after Cedar gives birth to her baby. She recalls a time when it used to snow and the feeling the cold brought her. She wonders if her child will ever get to see the snow, or if snow will be a distant memory by the time they are old enough. These occurrences throughout the book leave you with a feeling of fear regarding whether our changing climate could result in crazy circumstances such as evolution shifting backward.