Category Archives: 202

Discussion Questions– Persuasion

J3: Question One
Persuasion makes use of images of fall and falling. How do these images relate to Anne’s situation?
J3: Question Two
Anne and Captain Benwick (Wentworth’s friend) react to past losses in different ways. How does Rico’s chapter on the brain explain why these two people might react in different ways to loss or tragedy.View Full Description Hide Full Description
J3: Question Three
How do Anne and others react to the two accident that occur in this section of the novel? Do Anne’s reactions to these situations seem in keeping with her character? Why? Why not?

J4: Question One
Bath, the balance of power in the relationship between Anne and Captain Wentworth shifts.
How? Why?
J4: Question Two
Rico (105) suggests writing a guilt list and a blame list. Take any one character in Persuasion and create a guilt list and a blame list for that one character.
Do you think your character would have the self-awareness to compose lists like these? Why or Why not?
J4: Question Three
Compare Mrs. Smith’s attitude to her misfortunes to Captain Benwick’s attitude toward his misfortunes and to Anne’s attitude about hers.
What do their different attitudes reveal about each of them?

J5: Question One
The most famous act of persuading in Persuasion is, of course, Lady Russell’s persuading Anne to give up her engagement to Captain Wentworth. Look at one or two other acts of persuasion in the novel.

  • Who persuades whom to what?
  • Is the persuasion successful?
  • Are these positive or negative acts of persuading?
  • Is the persuader, right? Wrong?
  • How easily could you be persuaded?

J5: Question Two
Practice Rico’s yes/no “letting go” exercise (134) as any one character in Persuasion. Start with a yes/no word cluster, and then complete a yes/no word sketch for your character.
J5: Question Three
At the end of Chapter XX (127), Anne worries, “How, in all the peculiar disadvantages of their respective situations, would he [Wentworth] learn her real sentiments?” How does he? What does the way in which he discovers the truth reveal about Anne?

Discussion Questions-Monkeys

J1: Question One: Minot’s first chapter “Hiding” concerns itself not only with physical hiding but with other kinds of hiding as well. In your opinion, what are some of these characters hiding? Why?

J1: Question Two: Explain what you think Rico means by “naming and framing.” Give an example of an incident or emotion that one of the characters in Minot’s Monkeys might name or frame.

J1: Question Three: In Minot’s Monkeys, the narrator’s point of view shifts from first person in “Hiding” to third person in “Thanksgiving Day” and in the rest of the novel. What effect does this shift in the narrator’s point of view have on you as a reader? Why? Who is the first person narrator in “Hiding”? Is the narrator’s identity important?

J2: Question One: How does Rico suggest that clustering can be helpful in determining feelings and anxieties?
Take any one character in Monkeys, and imagine you are creating a cluster for that character.
What words might you include in your cluster?
What might those words reveal to you?
J2: Question Two: In Monkeys, the chapter “Accident,” ends with the frightening image:

. . . the Devil had swooped down and had landed and was lingering with them all, hulking in the middle of the kitchen table, settling down to stay. (126)

React to this image in the context of the two different accidents referred to in this chapter.

J2: Question Three: Minot uses the word “navigator” in both a literal and a metaphorical sense, literally, as someone who steers or manages a boat when sailing; metaphorically, as someone who steers or manages a family on an appropriate course.
Explore the idea of the “navigator” in Monkeys.
Who is the navigator? Who should be the navigator? Can there be more than one navigator in a family? Does this role shift during the course of the novel?