A Beautiful Mind

Emma Kitchen’s last memory of December 2010 came on the first day of the month, a little before 6:00 p.m.

It was cold, dark, and rainy when she walked out of the Peterson Family Athletic Center and hopped on her bicycle for the five-minute ride to Proctor, where dinner awaited.

Her friend Bronwyn Oatley ’13 was with her, and as the two pedaled down South Main Street and turned left onto the service road that would take them past the health center, the back of the Service Building, and up the hill toward Stewart Hall, they mostly chatted about the weather, how raw it felt as the cold rain pelted their faces.

They picked up their pace as they started up the hill, and in the dark they did not see the flash of a figure racing down the hill on his own bicycle heading directly for them. And he didn’t see them either.

The impact of the head-on collision sent Emma Kitchen ’14 flying backward off her bike, and the first part of her body to make impact with the ground was the back of her head when it thudded onto the pavement.

As Oatley raced to the health center several hundred yards away in frantic search of help, the other bicyclist waited helplessly by Kitchen’s side, as she lay unconscious and unresponsive on the asphalt.

Her skull was fractured, her brain hemorrhaging.

Yet her nightmare had yet to begin.


Emma Kitchen’s nightmare had everything to do with her accident and nothing to do with what she actually felt. For most, the pain would be the worst, the pain associated with the fractured skull, the cerebral contusions, the subarachnoid hemorrhages. (The medevac to Burlington’s Fletcher Allen Hospital, the three days in the intensive care unit, the four additional days in the hospital, the remaining weeks leading up to Christmas convalescing at home in Collingwood, Ontario—those don’t even compute, because she remembers none of it.)

And if you can push past the inconceivable pain (and she did, convincing herself that as an athlete she was tough, tough enough to overcome even a traumatic brain injury), then surely what will get you, what will be the source of your night terrors are what follows: the dizziness, the nausea, the spinal vibrations, the inability to hold a thought. It will be registering -0.5 on a 0 to 7 neurocognitive assessment IMPACT test when you plead to return to school in February for spring semester.

But no, that was not the source of Emma Kitchen’s own living hell. It wasn’t even the five months that she was confined to bed rest, ordered to sleep 18 hours a day, and denied all visual stimulus—no books, no television, no computer—and all but minimal social activity.
It wasn’t even the fleet of doctors, the neurosurgeons and neuropsychiatrists and physiotherapists and acupuncturists and naturopaths, as caring as they were, who could offer little more than a “sleep and you’ll get better” prescription.

Emma Kitchen’s nightmare, her living hell, was her solitary confinement within her own head.

She had no one to talk to who could tell her “I know what this is like.”

No one to tell her “I understand.”

No one to share a look that says “I know, but it gets better.”

Even as she healed, as the 18 hours of daily sleep over seemingly endless weeks returned her to the land of the living, she grieved.

And it was only when she finally found someone who had been through something similar, found someone to talk to from a place of shared experience, that she began to awaken from this horrible, debilitating feeling of isolation.

And this caused her to wonder: how many others are out there trapped in the same nightmare?


“I want to be absolutely clear: this is not about me. This is about the 1.2 million student-athletes under 20 who have been diagnosed with concussions during the past decade.”

Emma Kitchen is standing before a roomful of peers (and a handful of professional men and women) gathered in Middlebury’s Kirk Center on a cold early February morning. She is a poised young woman with a strong voice and contagious smile, and there is not a trace of the broken body and soul that resulted from her accident two years ago.

On this morning, she is winning over a group of entrepreneurs who are judging a contest that is the culmination of the winter term course MiddCORE. The contest is called the Next Big Idea, and the pitch that has captured everyone’s attention is a support network for student-athletes who have suffered head injuries.

Although the prevalence of concussions among athletes—and the serious neurological impact associated with such injuries—have seeped into the national consciousness through investigative journalism and awareness efforts promoted by the likes of the National Football League, that has not resulted in a corresponding increase in a “concussion community,” Kitchen says, a place where those suffering can share stories and offer support to one another.

Kitchen wants to change that, and for about 15 minutes she outlines her ambition to create a website that would fill the void. She rattles off statistics (the 1.2 million student-athletes who have been diagnosed with concussions during the past decade, the startling estimate that this figure could be closer to 8.4 million because so many go undiagnosed). She outlines a business plan; she talks start-up costs (about $10 thousand).

There are seven other Next Big Idea finalists in the room. Kitchen is the seventh to present, and as she wraps up her presentation, one notices a collective shoulder slump among her competitors, followed by admiring smiles. They know they’re now fighting for second place.

Since the beginning of February, Kitchen has not only won MiddCORE’s Next Big Idea title, but she has enlisted a business partner (her friend Kaitlin Surdoval ’12, who has suffered four concussions in her lifetime), and has won another competition, this one sponsored by the College’s Project on Creativity and Innovation in the Liberal Arts.

This latest achievement came with office space, alumni mentoring, and $3,000 in prize money. Phase one of their project begins this spring. Each week until the end of the academic year, Kitchen and Surdoval will bring student-athletes down to their studio in the Axinn Center to record testimonials. With the arrival of June, the two will hit the road, visiting campuses and summer programs, where they hope to add more stories to their database.

Their prize money is enough to get them started, Kitchen says, though she hopes to raise an additional $7,000 that will see them through phase one, with the launch of a video blog before autumn.

Emma Kitchen’s nightmare is over. But, she knows, others’ are just beginning.

Emma Kitchen can be reached at emma@concussionsspeak.com. When her website launches this summer, it can be found at www.concussionsspeak.com.

Comment Policy

We hope to create a lively discussion on MiddMag.com and invite you to add your voice. Please keep comments civil and relevant to the news item at hand. MiddMag.com may remove comments that do not follow these guidelines.

Leave a comment »

  1. I have know Emma most of her life. She has always been a person with a tenacious spirit, a thirst for knowledge and on a constant quest to change whats wrong and make it right. I am not surprised at all that this incredible young woman has taken a life altering experience and will use it to help others. I always knew Emma would make a difference!
    Congrqats Big E!!

  2. Very well done Emma, just a glimpse of what is yet to come, your future so bright ,this is a terrific idea , keep up the good work.

  3. The story “A Beautiful Mind” tells of student Emma Kitchen and a friend riding bicycle up a hill on campus: “in the dark, they did not see the flash of a figure racing down the hill on his own bicycle heading directly toward them. And he didn’t see them either.”

    The collision left Ms. Kitchen with a fractured skull and traumatic brain injury. The other bicyclist presumably was also a Middlebury student.

    Also not mentioned is the obvious: that the bicycles were not equipped with headlights. Is that to be considered so ordinary and normal as not even to be worthy of mention?

    Lights are required by law, though enforcement is lax. An educational institution has additional abilities to

    View More
    inform students, set rules and enforce them. The College’s Web site advises students to use lights and indicates that the law requires them, but does not mention any College policy compelling their use. The college’s Web page offers generally good but rather sketchy advice on other issues related to safe bicycling.

    Such tragedies as occurred to Ms. Kitchen are preventable. The benefits to students and to community morale of preventing them are clear enough. The benefits to the College of more students who finish, and of decades of potential alumni contributions from them, clearly outweigh the cost.

    John S. Allen ’68

    Technical Writer/Editor, http://sheldonbrown.com
    Author, Bicycling Street Smarts, http://bikexprt.com/streetsmarts/

    League of American Bicyclists Cycling Instructor #77-C
    Member, National Committee for Uniform Traffic Control Devices Bicycle Technical Committee.

    View Less
  4. Thank you so much for all the support. Concussions Speak just got our Facebook and Twitter pages up for the summer before we launch the site. Check it out and please spread the word! http://www.facebook.com/ConcussionsSpeak

  5. Emma, what a wonderful idea. I am not a Middlebury student or alum., but I have been where you were. My skull fracture and cerebellar contusion occured due to a fall from a horse. No helmet; I’m not sure that it would have made a difference. If you are interested in hearing about some of the long term effects feel free to contact me. Best wishes and congratulations on focusing on a significant medical issue that seems to be thought of as a minor issue until you actually confront the true problems.

  6. I’m just coming across this story today, as my daughter who is a junior in HS is starting the college process. She had 4 concussions in about 2 years, and developed depression and anxiety. We didn’t know they were related, but over a year later, many appointments at Dartmouth-Hitchcock with the neuropsych department and psychiatry have pretty much connected the dots. She was a top ski racer and did not ski at all this past winter. We’re on the road to recovery and have learned so much about depression. We learned that it is surprisingly common for a person in recovery from a concussion to receive another one. And that 1 in 10 adolescents

    View More
    and teens in this country will suffer from depression, certainly not all from concussions. It’s so common to put our kids right back into life after concussion, but in our daughters case it will take a full year for her brain to completely heal after the last one, which was in July 2013. I look forward to watching what your activities here (on your facebook page and website) can accomplish. Good luck and thanks for taking on this great project!

    View Less
  7. Emma Kitchen’s crash and her travails were entirely preventable, a fact which the article entirely fails to address. Kitchen, her friend and the other cyclist who struck her were evidently riding bicycles at night without headlights. That a college with the ability to reach its student population and to enforce the legal and common-sense requirement for a headlamp allowed this to happen is highly distressing

    A similar issue arose with the article in the winter 2014 issue about students’ hunting, http://sites.middlebury.edu/middmag/2014/02/26/the-call-of-the-wild/ . An alumnus had to write in to point out that two of the three student shown in that issue’s cover photo were carrying their rifles in ways contrary to established safety practices.

    I can only hope

    View More
    that my alma mater will come to attend to such issues

    View Less

Comment Policy

We hope to create a lively discussion on MiddMag.com and invite you to add your voice. Please keep comments civil and relevant to the news item at hand. MiddMag.com may remove comments that do not follow these guidelines.

Leave Comment